We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
I Ran Around NYC Looking for the Best Denim Shirt; These Are My Top Picks
Comfy classics from Aritzia, H&M, Banana Republic, and more.


Byrdie
Building a memorable wardrobe means stocking your closet with staples that outlast trends. Think white T-shirts, perfect work flats, and, of course, denim shirts. “A denim shirt is one of the most timeless and versatile pieces in any wardrobe,” says style expert and creative director Pam Arias. It’s the kind of staple that always adds texture and character to a look, no matter the season.”
As a fashion editor, I know all too well how important this piece is to a well-rounded spring wardrobe, so I scoured New York City for the must-have options of the season. From sleek vests to oversized staples, there’s no shortage of picks that’ll either serve as basics, statement makers, or a little bit of both. Below, I’ve selected the styles that stand out in terms of material, construction, sizing, fit, and wash.
Top Picks
Aritzia Denim Shirt at Aritzia.com
Jump to Review
& Other Stories Boxy Denim Jacket at Stories.com
Jump to Review
Madewell Denim High Crewneck Vest at Amazon$98$42
Jump to Review
Zara Denim Shirt at Zara.com
Jump to Review
H&M Blouse at Hm.com$35
Jump to Review
Banana Republic Tank at Banana Republic
Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Jump to Review
Best Overall
Aritzia 80’s Comfy Denim Shirt


Material: 87% cotton, 13% hemp | Sizes: XXS-XXL | Colors: 13
Ok, so I may have run all over the city to find the best denim top, but my absolute favorite is one that I own, and let me just say, I know this shirt hates to see me coming. I wear this oversized button-down all of the time, mainly because it lives up to its name and is just so comfy. Plus, it’s really oversized and shapeless, so it easily morphs into pretty much whatever you need. This is one that I’d buy in pretty much any of the 13 washes it offers, and it’ll never go out of style. I paired it with my Abercrombie black barrel jeans and Everlane fisherman sandals for a cool, effortless look.

Best Jacket-Turned-Shirt
& Other Stories Boxy Denim Jacket


Material: 80% cotton, 20% organic cotton | Sizes: XS-L | Colors: 2
Your jean jacket is just waiting to double as a shirt, and this boxy piece is proof. I paired it with the brand’s supersoft, buttery yellow satin midi dress (which I’m now obsessed with) and my Dolce Vita cowboy boots, and was instantly impressed. You can easily wear it with jeans of a similar wash, a satin skirt, or really whatever you can dream up; the options are endless.

Best Vest
Madewell Denim High Crewneck Vest


Material: 100% cotton | Sizes: 00-16 | Colors: 2
As the days get warmer and longer, it makes sense to think about statement pieces that will easily fit into your wardrobe. This vest from Madewell is such a sleek and flattering way to rock a denim top without breaking a sweat. I paired it with the brand’s super wide-leg jeans for a sleek, uniform look. I’d go up one size because it was a bit snug, but it was so well made and gorgeous that I just had to include it.

Best T-Shirt
Zara TRF Crop Denim Shirt


Material: 100% cotton | Sizes: XS-XXL | Colors: 1
Zara is always a good destination for wardrobe basics, and this denim T-shirt is the perfect example. It’s super lightweight and comes in a versatile wash that pairs easily with many looks. I tried it with white cuffed pants to lean into the season, but this would look great with Bermuda shorts or a bright, printed skirt.

Best Pullover
H&M Pullover Twill Blouse


Material: 100% cotton | Sizes: XS-XXL | Colors: 3
I’ll admit it, H&M surprised me with their variety of denim tops. They had the basic button-downs, of course, but their take on the denim pullover was refreshing. I tossed this one on with a linen maxi skirt, but I also tried it with flowy pinstriped linen–blend pants, and it delivered such a nautical vibe. This is a piece I’d throw in my bag for a trip to any seaside destination. Martha’s Vineyard, anyone?

Best Tank
Banana Republic Denim Trapeze Tank


Banana Republic is one of those no-brainer stops for elevated classics, and although they had so many really cool options (like this strapless top), my favorite look was this easy, breezy tank. It’s a piece that’s just so easy to throw on in the summer. I paired it with the brand’s white poplin skirt, but this would also be adorable with black capri pants (which are back, by the way).

Other Options We Love


This strapless number is great for those nights when you need to make a major statement.


If bulky or oversized isn’t your speed, this classic slim fit is ideal for you.


Another gorgeous pullover option for those no-fuss days; this time with an ultra-cool zipper detail.


Looking to spice up your life? This asymmetrical top is perfect for special occasions and is sure to turn heads.
What to Look for When Buying a Denim Shirt
- Material: For a sturdy, jean-like feel, we recommend 100% cotton denim shirts. However, if you prefer a bit of stretch, look for one blended with a small amount of spandex or elastane. Chambray can also be a good option for those who want something lighter and more breathable.
- Fit and Cut: Denim shirts range from boxy, oversized, and longline boyfriend styles to cropped and tailored fits. When choosing a cut, consider how you plan on wearing the shirt. A more relaxed style is best for layering over leggings and fitted tops, but you’ll want a more fitted shirt for tucking into pants.
- Wash: You also have the option of various denim washes. As with jeans, it’s ultimately a matter of personal preference and what other pieces you’ll wear with the shirt. Dark indigo can be a little dressier, whereas light, distressed, and bleached washes lend an easy-breezy, summery appeal. Then there are alternatives to blue, like black, white, gray, and even some bolder hues.
Meet Our Expert
For this article, Byrdie consulted with the following expert:
- Pam Arias is a style expert and creative director based in Miami, Florida.
Why Trust Byrdie
Dominique Hobdy is a senior editor with over 10 years of experience writing and editing for major media brands. She holds a B.A. in Print/Online Journalism from Howard University. Her area of expertise is fashion, and she’s covered season after season of spring transitional trends. For this story, she considered current trends, tried-and-true tricks for this time of year, and sustainable brands that are delivering next-level style with an ethical ethos.
Source URL: https://www.byrdie.com/best-denim-shirts-11725424

