Meet the Composers of the Survivor Soundtrack—And the Fans Recreating It Online
One of my early internet obsessions, inspired by a fascination with shows like Total Drama Island and Survivor, was participating in “camps.” People who weren’t old enough to go on Survivor would host their own reality shows on YouTube. They’d mostly play out over YouTube DMs: we’d scheme in private-messages and essentially role-play Survivor; the host would make a video announcing who was voted out, as if it was a TV episode. I eventually started hosting my own—a simulacra of a simulacra—enlisting friends from school to compete along with other kid-hobbyists online. I wanted my show to look as sleek and professional as possible, which eventually led me to discover that bedroom producers were taking the music from Survivor and remastering it so all the dialogue was removed. These were perfect—they made my videos feel real.
It’s been 25 years since Survivor redrew the map and changed reality TV forever, and tonight is the premiere of its 48th season. Somehow its fandom has only gotten more deliriously diehard over the years. It’s spawned a slew of niches, like “edgic” heads who hyper-focus on the way the editors portion screentime, and people who host their own ORGs, or online fanmade reality games. Most intriguing is the subculture of fans hooked on Survivor music; they revere the themes for Tribal Council, the point in the game where contestants are brutally ostracized, like they’re Mozart compositions.
I’ve probably spent dozens of hours listening to these soundtracks, despite the fact that they’re not really “music” in the proper sense. This isn’t stuff you could play at a picnic or in the car with friends, and even most Survivor fans would probably scoff at the idea of listening to them for fun. It feels closer to video game soundtracks—a patchwork of audiovisual symmetry, thuds and shivers shadowing every spike of tension on-screen. The composers have a WarioWare library’s worth of FX: Tiny alarms for a shocked face; rippling winds to signal someone in deep thought; kitschy screams to ratchet up the suspense; the gratifying whoosh when a vote parchment is read. When Tiffany Ervin came under threat during a TC and we thought she might play an immunity idol, the percussion and synthetic risers fluttered in sync with the frantic yet subtle movement of her pupils.
Maybe my favorite in recent years was the theme for Survivor season 45 contestant Kellie Nalbandian’s elimination, which began curiously calm, tricking viewers into thinking that another player was set to go. But when the first “Kellie” vote appears, the music falls out and a churning drumbeat comes in. It was similar to Kishan Patel’s blindside last season; the music almost completely slips away, capturing the pure despair that overtakes him and his alliance members as they lose hope.
As someone who finds most reality TV themes gratingly over-the-top—sorry, The Traitors—I’ve always been curious why the Survivor soundtracks scratch my brain like nothing else. It feels similar to the way I used to listen to Bourne Supremacy chase themes to power myself during algebra homework, or Relaxing Pokémon Music compilations while locked-in on a college essay at 2 a.m. It’s instrumental music that’s much more intertwined with the neurons in my brain and my personal history than, say, a magnificent Bach piece or high-wire jazz fusion, and it’s not as limp and lifeless as lo-fi beats to study to. It reminds me of all the years I spent watching the show next to my mom on the couch every Wednesday, all those times I fiddled around on a clunky Dell laptop hosting camps and having fun. It may be tacky, even at times tasteless music, the antithesis of hip and cool, but it sounds sweet to me.
The show’s composers have changed—Russ Landau made some of the most iconic themes like the soaring intro “Ancient Voices,” along with David Vanacore. One of the more recently hired composers for the show, Sam Fuller, 27, was only three when the first episode of Survivor aired. Now he’s written hundreds of themes, starting with season 41; he was brought on along with members of the Burnett Music team after host Jeff Probst heard their work on the World’s Toughest Race. “They’ve got 40 seasons of Survivor music,” he says. “We were brought on to give it a different flavor. We’d try to make it a bit more filmic.” Fuller, who produces the themes from his home studio in the UK, explains that they’ll receive briefs and references—“things that start dark and finish light,” “triumphant,” James Horner’s Apocalypto soundtrack—and sculpt themes ranging from 90 seconds to two minutes long. He uses Landau’s sample library and plays real instruments when he can, like guitar, shakers, and a conch that his parents brought back from Saint Lucia. “I’ve done some funny vocals here and there, chanting and heavy breathing,” he says, which he’ll distort digitally.
Writing music for reality TV is a highly collaborative process. While editors will sometimes use a full theme, they’re also used as raw putty; Fuller sends them stems and myriad versions of a track, as well as specific bars and patterns they can use as loops to extend a moment. The editors will layer cymbals, transition sounds, and tribal screams to accent the actions onscreen. Fuller’s been writing for this upcoming season, Survivor 48, since October 2024; he’ll continue sending them music, even while it’s airing, since they’re still editing the later episodes. He used to try to finish a theme in one day, but now he’s taking double the time: “Less music, but better music.”
CBS barely posts any of the Survivor incidental themes and underscores as stand-alone instrumentals. As a result, an increasingly large cottage industry of producer-pirates has spawned to fill the vacuum. These YouTubers will upload a perfectly seamless reassembly of a Tribal Council theme just a day after it airs live on CBS, to a community of thousands of fans who feverishly anticipate every new drop.
Maybe the most notable producer-pirate is DaliRet, a 34-year-old whose real name is Jorge Alvarado. He estimates he’s spent hundreds of hours carefully cleaning up and releasing Survivor music. He started in 2013 with “Blindside Time,” his version of a popular theme that soundtracked dramatic scenes where players would be voted out in a shocking “blindside” fashion. His process resembles something like a paleontologist at a dig site hunting for fossil-frags to assemble into a full skeleton. He’ll rewatch entire seasons hunting for the micro-bits of a theme without dialogue, and stitch everything together into a flawless whole. When he can’t find a passage that’s dialogue-free, he uses Audacity to remove the vocals. It might take DaliRet 20 hours to reconstruct a two-minute theme. The piecing together of one intricate theme involved sifting through 56 episodes’ worth of Tribal Council content. Entirely self-taught, Alvarado has subsequently turned his hobby into a part-time career by editing and audio mixing for commercials and fanmade games.
The Survivor music fandom is small but fervent; beyond DaliRet, there’s TheMaestro, who has remastered not only TC themes but soundtracks from challenges, camp life, and cold opens. The current king is MUD Music, who’s de-vocalized pretty much every vote theme from the last batch of seasons. There’s even a dedicated Reddit page, where diehards rip the rips, providing an archive in case themes get copyright struck.
The relationship between the show’s actual composers and the admirer-pirates has been fiery at times. Alvarado, who just returned after a three-year hiatus, tells me he left after Fuller called him and other YouTube producers out on Instagram for ripping his music. Alvarado had started a Patreon, saying he would try to remake any theme someone requested. Another creator, Survivorfan191, claimed that many of their videos were once copyright-struck.
Fuller appreciates that fans love the themes but says it’s frustrating to see people threaten his income by treating the music like it’s a public commodity. “It’s a hard balance,” he says. “I don’t want to bash these guys for being enthusiastic about the music everyone writes for Survivor because it’s the most flattering thing. I just think the way they go about it in getting hold of it isn’t quite right… maybe one day, CBS will be up for releasing some music, and it’ll be awesome.” Start the pressure campaign now!
What I’m listening to:
Source URL: https://pitchfork.com/thepitch/meet-the-composers-of-the-survivor-soundtrack-and-the-fans-recreating-it-online/
