Friendship Review: A Life of Not-So-Quiet Desperation
Across genres, films about suburban life present it as an apparatus that saps its adult inhabitants of agency, and therefore happiness. It demands money, it demands conformity. But the people who choose to stay in or move to these enclaves have done just that—chosen. While it’s comforting to imagine that the things we believe make us unhappy on an existential level are beyond our control, it’s seldom true. One of the most uncomfortable questions we can ask ourselves is: How much of the fear and antipathy that mars adult life is imposed on us, and how much are we conjuring ourselves?
Of course, Andrew DeYoung’s Friendship, which premiered at TIFF last fall and opens wide this weekend, does not make any overt attempt to answer this question. But rather than confine its scope to the contemporary “male loneliness epidemic,” the film gets at a more longstanding despair. DeYoung, a veteran director of television comedy, wrote the script for Tim Robinson, whose Craig loses his wife, career, and a potential new friendship all while—at least in his mind—simply trying to be normal. For all the contemporary discourse about the digital fragmentation of life and the resurgence of open misogyny in pop culture, Friendship could have been released, with a few tweaks, at nearly any point in the last half-century. It’s sort of like if all the characters in American Beauty knew who Adam22 was and had also seen and hated American Beauty.
When the film opens, Craig works a delightfully ill-defined marketing job, which he explains at one point as an exercise in triggering addiction in peoples’ brains. His wife, Tammy (a subtly severe Kate Mara), is a cancer survivor who tells a support group that she worries she may never orgasm again. (Craig, sitting next to her, smiles weakly.) Tammy is having an obvious emotional affair; Craig is A Lot, wailing and fixating the way Robinson does. The bits in Friendship resemble his beloved sketch show, I Think You Should Leave, but are necessarily tethered to the suburban and banal. They do not escalate toward true absurdity, and instead disintegrate into simple discomfort for those onscreen, often including Craig himself. DeYoung doesn’t overplay this dynamic—there are no lurches toward real, weepy pathos—but it does give Friendship an unnerving undercurrent, and not always for the best.
Whether to get some space from his inanity, be able to spend more time with her ex-boyfriend, or simply encourage him to be a person, Tammy urges Craig to make friends with Austin (Paul Rudd), the affable evening news weatherman who moves in down the street. Early on, Friendship seems as if it might be setting up a classic comedy two-hander about a pair of oddballs who are alien to one another. Instead, Austin comes to loom in Craig’s life as a symbol of what he cannot be or have. Austin’s strange, too: He collects archaic weapons, scurries through the city’s sewer system for fun, and has a soft sociopathic streak about his work. But, crucially, he has friends, a group of guys who come over semi-regularly to drink light beers and bullshit. Craig is naturally—chemically—unable to hang.
In 2009, Rudd co-starred with Jason Segel in I Love You, Man, one of those aforementioned two-handers, which is largely forgettable but serves as a key bit of connective tissue in the middle of 21st-century comedy. It was directed by John Hamburg, who had previously written Zoolander; where Zoolander was a more inventive and acidic descendent of the SNL comedies of the 1990s, 2004’s Along Came Polly, which Hamburg also directed, was the romantic comedy model of the ‘90s already running on fumes. With I Love You, Man, he shifted again, this time to be downstream from the Judd Apatow comedies that had made Rudd an above-the-title star. Those Apatow movies, all improv-heavy, are basically two-dimensional xeroxes of superior Brooks movies (Albert and James L.)—long, baggy dramedies that treated normal domesticity as a comfortable if inevitable end point.
This is from a distinctly different era in comedy, creatively and industrially. Friendship is smaller and opens, even with its A24 distribution, to a bleaker marketplace; more interestingly, the sketch show that made its star famous—itself a cult object with modest reach—looms so large that it nearly subsumes the movie. The best scenes here feel like the first halves of scenes from I Think You Should Leave, but pivot at some point toward a recognizably adult sort of melancholy. Rather than enhance either or both of the comedy and drama, it has the unfortunate effect of drawing the viewer out of the text itself and making him or her wonder about editing, rewrites, the filmmakers’ success or failure rather than the characters’.
This is especially unfortunate because the plot itself is quite harrowing. In short order, Craig alienates, then begins to stalk Austin, an arc that is recreated with graver stakes when Tammy runs away and is pursued by Craig (and the police, and a team of volunteers) as a missing person. Even after Tammy is found and has shed her tinfoil rescue blanket, at a party for her homecoming, Craig is cast off, eventually marooning himself in the driveway as Patton (Connor O’Malley) ends a toast by lecturing those assembled about how American troops withdrawing from Afghanistan was a mistake.
Friendship is one of the funnier comedies to get wide release this decade; it also grows a bit thin, even at 97 minutes. This is because of the inherent discordance between its bit-bit-bit-bit comedic engine and that suburban ennui it aims to communicate. This is a problem not of ideology, but of architecture. The movie lags, then strains to get to the next game at the exact time the malaise sets in. And so the back half of Friendship is buoyed by a couple of mercifully absurdist set pieces (e.g., Craig feeling a little bit scammed by a teen named Tboy who charges him an exorbitant amount of money to lick an allegedly psychedelic frog, but still slinking out of the cell phone store’s storeroom), but ends up bogged down by the dramatic stakes with which it chose to saddle itself.
It’s also an oddly sincere ode to friends. Even when some of Austin’s buddies lapse into therapyspeak, their group is not pitched as a place for enlightenment, or even emotional support as such. It’s just somewhere to be. Garages, lousy bars, the corners of parking lots where allied coworkers chain smoke—DeYoung is arguing, again and again, that these totally unremarkable scraps of communion are the antidote to the latent evil that comes with isolation. After all, during Friendship’s climax, when Craig waves a loaded gun at a room full of his peers and demands they make small talk with him, it makes a perverse bit of sense: Who wouldn’t kill to hang with the fellas?
Source URL: http://pitchfork.com/thepitch/friendship-movie-review-a-life-of-not-so-quiet-desperation/
