Trends

A Sexy Cardigan Is the Winter Holy Grail Product—Just Ask Elphaba

November 24, 2025

Roy Rochlin/Getty Images

Is this a safe space? I have to admit, I have yet to see Wicked: For Good—and probably will not—but much of the chatter around the Vogue office has to do with the film’s so-called “sex cardigan.” Set to “As Long As You’re Mine,” Elphaba (Cynthia Erivo) sloughs off her clothes in favor of black lingerie and a gray melange sweater so chunky it’s earned its own nickname. (Paul Tazewell, come get that second consecutive Oscar nomination.)

But, while I’m not exactly ready to adopt an Ozian oversized chunky knit, I—a born-and-raised Californian with limited exposure to wintry mixes—have a newfound appreciation for cardigans. As I’ve learned to adapt to colder weather, I’ve been pleased to discover that almost no other item of clothing is as fun—and, dare I say, sexy—as a cardigan. They’re so versatile! Wear it over a white tee or with nothing underneath at all, buttoned up to the top or totally open. You’re never locked into one style.

katieholmes in khaite sweater

Katie Holmes.

Photo: Backgrid

“But what’s so sexy about a sweater?” you may be asking. I’d reckon that a cardigan begets confidence like almost no other item of clothing. It’s customizable to the wearer’s comfort and what, after all, is hotter than being secure in yourself? And if you aren’t buying that platitude, may I just remind you of Katie Holmes’s Khaite cardigan and bralette set?

HOLLYWOOD CALIFORNIA  NOVEMBER 18 Paul Mescal attends the Gladiator II Los Angeles Premiere at the TCL Chinese Theatre...
Jesse Grant/Getty Images
Los Angeles CA  EXCLUSIVE  Model Kaia Gerber was spotted enjoying coffee with a friend in Los Angeles. The fashion icon...
BACKGRID USA

Elphaba isn’t alone in her love of a sexy cardigan. Kaia Gerber and Paul Mescal have both showed us just how hot the button-up sweater can be. Gerber demonstrated the cardigan for warmer climates, wearing a red sweater left mostly unbuttoned, sleeves pushed up above her elbows with nothing underneath. Mescal, meanwhile, added a gray cardi to his Gladiator II premiere look, wearing it over a white tee and under a structured black blazer for a casual-cozy touch.

And, of course, with her knitwear brand Guest In Residence, we can always count on Gigi Hadid to rock a cardigan, like the tomato-hued sweater(s) she wore out in the streets of New York, or her sister Bella Hadid, who once sported a mustard cardigan with just the top button clasped. Jennifer Lopez gave a new meaning to the sweater set in a brown Gucci knit with a matching pair of shorts. Any way you spin it, you really can’t go wrong. So if you’re planning a special occasion this coming winter and want to feel your best self, grab your favorite cardigan and button up.

Shop a selection of celeb-coded cardigans, below.

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, Sweatshirt, and Coat

J.Crew

featherweight cardigan

$168

J.CREW

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, Cardigan, and Coat

Dôen

Petra cardigan

$280

NET-A-PORTER

&Daughter

Ada wool cardigan

$595

NET-A-PORTER

Guest in Residence

Elle cashmere cardigan

$365

NET-A-PORTER

Alex Mill

Taylor cardigan

$178

SHOPBOP

Leset

Jesse cardigan

$390

NET-A-PORTER

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, Cardigan, and Coat

Nili Lotan

March cardigan

$670

NET-A-PORTER

Zara

ruffled cardigan

$50

ZARA

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

Cos

Fair Isle cardigan

$259

COS

Sea

Hollis knit cardigan

$425

SHOPBOP