A century-old trail network on the eastern edge of Montana’s Crazy Mountains has officially been closed to the public, marking a flashpoint in a highly contested federal land swap. In an in-depth investigation co-published by WyoFile and Floodlight, details have emerged regarding how the U.S. Forest Service relinquished public access to historic low-elevation routes — the Sweetgrass and East Trunk trails — early last year. This terrain was handed over to the ultra-exclusive Yellowstone Club, a private mountaintop retreat for billionaires located 100 miles away in Big Sky. For lifelong locals and conservationists, the swap represents a troubling precedent regarding the creeping privatization of America’s public resources under the current political landscape.
- Related: Montana Ski Trips Are Getting a Lot More Interesting—and It’s Not Just About Skiing Anymore
The agreement, officially designated as the East Crazy Inspiration Divide Land Exchange, was finalized by federal officials in January 2025. On paper, the public traded roughly 4,000 acres of public land into private hands in exchange for just over 6,000 acres of private holdings. However, independent appraisals and local critics note a severe disparity in the actual value and utility of the trade. The public surrendered prime, low-lying valleys filled with timber and wildlife to clear the way for the developer’s massive luxury expansion, which includes an 18-hole golf course and private spa at the newly acquired 18,000-acre Crazy Mountain Ranch. In return, the public received steep, rocky, high-elevation alpine territory. Public documents show an independent appraiser even warned that parts of the new public parcels require advanced rock-climbing skills to navigate, making them virtually useless for average hikers and traditional hunting.
This transaction has triggered intense scrutiny over the political leverage wielded by the elite club, whose membership rolls feature tech titans, financial elites, and high-level political figures. Public property records reviewed by investigative journalists reveal that current Interior Secretary Doug Burgum — the man tasked with overseeing 500 million acres of federal land — owns a $22 million condo inside the Yellowstone Club and has pulled in up to $1 million in rental income from it. Burgum, who has publicly referred to federal lands as “assets on America’s balance sheet,” did not divest from his luxury real estate stakes upon taking office. Ethics experts have raised significant red flags over these ties as the administration aggressively moves to downsize federal protections, slash budgets for the National Park Service, and explore paths to sell off public parcels to private developers.
Public lands advocates warn that the outcome in the Crazies is a clear indicator of what lies ahead for federal acreage across the country. Though roughly two-thirds of the 1,000-plus public comments submitted to the Forest Service explicitly opposed the exchange, federal managers moved forward with the deal regardless. By allowing large private estates to piece together a protective ring of private ownership around the remaining public core, critics argue that the federal government is effectively locking ordinary citizens out of accessible wilderness, transforming shared American heritage into an isolated playground reserved exclusively for the ultra-wealthy.