[analyse_image type=”featured” src=”https://www.byrdie.com/thmb/s61EyKw9J-0gE69BAXidWYa0OUI=/1500×0/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/byr-loafers-for-women-tout-92a62801f85247f4939e1aa5c868a38d.jpg”]
We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
I Was a Loafer Skeptic, but These 12 Classic, Ultra-Comfortable Styles Won Me Over
I finally get the hype.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/IMG_3971-d4c886bd80df4be09984b7aa2b99218a.jpg)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-loafers-for-women-tout-92a62801f85247f4939e1aa5c868a38d.jpg)
Byrdie
TL;DR
If you’re going to add one loafer to your collection, we recommend J.Crew’s Winona Penny Loafer. We were able to wear this loafer right out of the box without blisters, and the classic design goes with everything. If you prefer a loafer with a bit more edge, check out Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers. They are a platform loafer that doesn’t feel too bulky, and they come in fun colors like cow print, in addition to black and brown.
Believe me—it was going to take a lot to pry the white sneaker off my feet. I once believed it was the ultimate pair-all shoe, the only one capable of going with everything, from baggy jeans to sleek slips. That was until the loafer made its way into my life. Now I understand how a structured shoe—one that is both sleek and timeless—can feel sharp in style but comfortable in wear. Whether trekking to the train for a work commute or heading straight to cocktail hour, these celebrity-endorsed shoes truly can do it all.
After testing several pairs of loafers, I’m hooked, just like so many of our editors. If you’re wondering which pairs are truly worth making room for in your own closet, read on to shop the best loafers for women that we tested in our daily lives and fell in love with—with no blisters in sight.
Top Picks
J.Crew Penny Loafer at Jcrew.com$198
Jump to Review
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers at Amazon$165$99
Jump to Review
Favorite Daughter Loafer at Nordstrom$265
Jump to Review
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers at Revolve$275
Jump to Review
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer at Amazon$178
Jump to Review
Mango Penny Loafers at Mango.com$140
Jump to Review
Quince Horsebit Loafer at Quince$70
Jump to Review
Larroudé Loafer at Larroude.com$375
Jump to Review
Sezane Loafers at Sezane.com$230
Jump to Review
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer at Anntaylor.com$158$58
Jump to Review
Best Overall
J.Crew Penny Loafer
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/jcrew-winona-penny-loafer-ee78a18c36144e5482738f35c54cdbe0.jpg)
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 3
This was the first pair that I tried, and they were like the unicorn of pennies. That’s because—to put it quite simply—I couldn’t find anything wrong with them. It’s a pair that keeps a flatteringly low profile, devoid of any fussy accents. Right out of the box, this pair had a rich leather scent. But what really converted me, and made me finally forgo my ballets for work commutes, was that I could walk four miles to and from my office without a single blister in sight. But compliments from strangers were plenty.
Best Chunky
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/dolce-vita-tiggy-loafers-61408118ad7d4bb382be979512bb04e5.jpg)
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic outsole | Size Range: 5-15 | Colors: 4
A chunky style is like the cooler older sister of the loafer world. It gives a bit of edge, without straying too far from its origins. But for those who think they’re too punk rock for their wardrobe, let us introduce you to an easygoing version that proves a platform can be worn every day. We tested these while going for quick meetups and coffee runs and quickly realized they’re exceptional for long walks, too. That’s because there’s a substantial amount of weight on them—great for wintery outings—all without feeling too dense or bulky.
Ali Webb, associate style editor: “The design is so comfortable. They didn’t require any break-in time, and modern details like a chunky sole and a crinkled patent finish (or statement hues, if you choose) ensure that this is not your grandparents’ preppy shoe.”
Best for Work
Favorite Daughter Loafer
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/favorite-daughter-lola-loafer-a47e2f31a8e3482bb2c9ed4aec8a0569.jpg)
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic lining, rubber sole | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
A classically cool loafer, crafted by Favorite Daughter (yes—the sisters who also created the Byrdie-obsessed show Nobody Wants This), is the ideal mix of relaxed and collegiate. Associate Editor Emily Cieslak tested these and said they were easy to break in, but the real sell is in the color: a gorgeous burgundy croc, for when you want something that feels more luxe than black or brown. Sport these with cashmere sweaters and trousers or even a pair of slouchy jeans, if you want more of a juxtaposed look.
Emily Cieslak, associate editor: “I think these loafers are a great intro to the style for anyone hesitant to try. Think of them like your favorite ballet flats, but with a bit more edge.”
Most Comfortable
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/flattered-bon-bon-suede-loafers-bourbon-f4ca5ebbc81841e6b2460f4995e1d23e.jpg)
Materials: Cow Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
If you’re looking for a loafer with soft, supple leather, these are it. When we tried this pair, equipped with ruching around the almond toe, we immediately felt the impact of trading in a stiff, synthetic shoe for one made of high-quality material. Not only is the look very Scandi—thanks to its buttery, worn-in leather and soft sheen—but our tester said she couldn’t believe a loafer could be so comfortable (there was no poking or rubbing at the ankles).Plus, the tiny heel (about 10 millimeters) gives this minimalist pair an elevated feel—literally.
Maddie Barber, writer: “[These are] STUNNING—such incredible quality, made with supple, soft leather.”
Best Penny Loafer
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/madewell-the-grayson-penny-loafer-ac8e891d26794f9bb34bffdf49ec979c.jpg)
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: Black
A true no-brainer investment, these Madewell penny loafers take our top spot thanks to their smooth, sleek leather construction and sophisticated silhouette. They read high-end at first glance but deliver where it actually matters: comfort. Rarely does a brand-new shoe feel broken in on day one, yet Byrdie’s Editorial Director Holly Rhue was pleasantly surprised to find these blissfully ache- and blister-free straight out of the box. And aside from those sturdy leather uppers, these feature a faux penny—a refined yet nostalgic touch.
Holly Rhue, editorial director: “In terms of chunk factor, these are the Goldilocks of loafers. They’re not so flat that I can feel every grain of gravel under the sole, nor are they so chunky that I feel like I’m in lug soles.”
Best Suede
Mango Penny Loafers
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/mango-suede-penny-loafers-23ebe08cd37d406c92229ae6232232ed.jpg)
Materials: Bovine leather | Size Range: 5-10 | Colors: 1
Without wavering too much into boat-shoe territory, these suede pennies from Mango keep things unfussy and casual, while still reading as a loafer. They bring just the right amount of texture and warmth to an outfit, especially in the winter when I just want something that feels easy on cold mornings but appears refined. While I’m glad to have this shoe’s full-grain counterpart in my closet, I adored how effortlessly these broke in because of the flexible vamps.
Best Backless
Quince Horsebit Loafer
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/quince-italian-leather-horsebit-loafer-f778aa2899cc469eb2128c1e4f8efcbe.jpg)
Materials: Italian calf leather upper| Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
In case you haven’t heard, the backless loafer is back, and this is one 2016 trend we’re happy to revive without cringing. Truly a business-in-the-front, easy-going-in-the-back shoe, these loafers are structured like an open-backed mule, but appear to be a classic flat at the toe. They immediately reminded me of the iconic Gucci Princetown loafers when I unboxed them, but with an enticing under-$100 price tag. I loved the gorgeous mocha color, which is rich enough to sub in for when your classic black pair feels a bit drab.
Best Designer
Larroudé Loafer
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/larroude-katherine-loafer-edeedced4f224354b31f7c80560cdc6e.jpg)
Materials: Luster calf leather | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
Sometimes, a shoe costs a pretty penny—pun fully intended—and you quickly realize it’s not functional whatsoever. What I love about Larroudé, though, is that they’re quite reliable and even more stylish. These are the rare shoes that look like they should hurt but don’t. The low, flat sole is rubberized for comfort and grip, the classic loafer silhouette keeps them wearable, and a thinly laid gold ornament adds just the right amount of polish to an everyday flat.
Best for Wide Feet
Sezane Loafers
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/sezane-albane-loafers-729afa3a57c6451d9232015d50f782ff.jpg)
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 4-11 | Colors: 2
For us wider-footed girlies, Sézane has made a platformed leather with a wider fit that gives height without being aggressively chunky. I loved pairing these with baggy proportions, since they reinforce the relaxed, oversized feel. The rubber outsole keeps these durable (I wore them on a very rainy day, and honestly didn’t miss my rain boots at all—the same can’t be said for my Oxfords or ballet flats). They feel genuinely tactile underfoot, yet still read feminine to onlookers as I hustled through the streets of Manhattan.
Best Animal Print
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/ann-taylor-animal-print-suede-loafer-612e9c2e303f4d16a3cc13a2fef75b4f.jpg)
Materials: Suede | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
For those of us who believe leopard is neutral, this playful pair from Ann Taylor is a wonderful way to incorporate animal print into your footwear. Made from 100% suede, this classic loafer is on the cheaper side for shoes made from the same materials. We love that, of course—but we also love the detailing at the front of this shoe that adds a textural flair.
Best Brown
M.Gemi The Brenda
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/mgemi-the-brenda-cec46117db2b4722807a2cf196fad8a6.jpg)
Materials: Italian kid suede upper with nappa leather details, Italian leather lining | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
M.Gemi knows how to make an investment piece, like these biscuit-colored beauties, which are also available in a chocolate-y brown and—the colorway I’ve been eyeing—a gorgeous and funky snakeskin. The standout feature of these otherwise low-profile loafers is the soft leather twisted, tubular bands that adorn the toebox. They’re also made with a Sacchetto suede (something I, admittedly, had to Google, which is an Italian, hand-stitched technique where the lining and insole are sewn together like a “little bag”). And that kind of craftsmanship shines through, as they feel and look high-end, though I would note that they probably do work best for narrower feet, as the quarters were on the tighter end.
Best Casual
Cos Leather Loafers
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/cos-classic-leather-loafers-687eefb460ba47c69a2bf2b17bc5b9c7.jpg)
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 6-12 | Colors: 1
For a shoe that looks (and feels!) more like a slipper, that even the most unconvinced loafer skeptic could find themselves in, enter the Cos leather loafer. As a shoe that could be mistaken for something by The Row, these pared-down, minimalist loafers beg the question: Why wear anything else when they are as refined as an Oxford shoe but as comfortable as indoor footwear? Our tester asked herself the same question, noting how comfortable they were and how the materials felt, likely due to the 100% leather, which made for a breathable, natural interior and a flexible sole.
Shannon Stubbs, writer: “I’m not really a fan of loafers, so it was hard to find a pair that fit my style. The soft leather gives them a casual, understated vibe that I think standard loafers don’t have.”
What to Look for in Loafers for Women
- Materials: When it comes to loafers, real leather remains the gold standard: it softens over time, molds to your foot, and can last for years with proper care (AKA resoling and conditioning). Faux or “vegan” leather tends to be more affordable but can stay rigid and often cracks or peels rather than aging gracefully. Liz Teich, a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist, tells Byrdie that most vegan leathers are made from plastic, meaning they won’t biodegrade and rarely hold up long-term. So if you’re looking for a more sustainable option: Go real.
- Texture: Some textures our experts are loving, and recommend for your closet:
- Smooth leatheris both timeless and long-lasting, adds Teich. It’s easiest to maintain, and it’s the most versatile.
- Pebbled leather feels softer right out of the box and is more forgiving of scuffs.
- Suede (think camel or chocolate) adds warmth and richness, but save it for your second or third pair—and always spray with protectant, warns Teich.
- Pony hair brings texture without shouting, and it’s perfect for neutral dressers craving something a tad bit more memorable.
- Fit:Lauren Sharkey, a Chicago-based personal stylist, notes that most blister complaints come from too much room, especially at the heel. If you can slip your heel out without using your hands, expect rubbing. Experts recommend sticking close to your true size and erring slightly on the snug. That’s because leather stretches with wear and warmth. “I’d recommend sizing to the foot, not the sock—instead opt for a thin (ideally cashmere) sock that adds the most minimal padding to your foot,” says Sharkey. “I prefer this aesthetically as well,”
- Color: If you’re just starting to build your loafer collection, Sharkey recommends a low-profile, no-hardware black loafer. “From there, I’d prioritize a rich caramel or chocolate suede pair that delivers depth, texture, and warmth to a look. And I’d round it out with a high gloss black patent loafer for a statement finish,” says Sharkey. “If you tend to wear mostly neutrals, like myself and my clients, a deep bordeaux or burgundy is a lovely addition — again, not your first pair but an additive pair. They punctuate a tonal look, from rich browns to cool heather grays or blacks. They also soften a denim-on-denim look.”
How We Tested Loafers for Women
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-larroude-katherine-loafer-morgan-sullivan-closeup-1-b4492c450cd04f23842894323d71817a.jpeg)
Byrdie
Byrdie editors and writers tested multiple pairs of loafers for a month. Each of us looked for the things you actually care about when shopping for the best pair of shoes: comfort, durability (we did a lot of walking, long commutes, and serious breaking in), quality of materials, and how long they took to soften up. And, transparently, if a pair tore up our ankles, it didn’t make the list.
Meet Our Experts
For this article, we interviewed several stylists for advice on how to shop for and style loafers.
- Joy Asibey-Gabriel is a personal stylist and feminine adornment coach.
- Lauren Sharkey is a Chicago-based personal stylist.
- Liz Teich is a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist.
Why Trust Byrdie
Byrdie contributor Morgan Sullivan has over half a decade of experience in the beauty and fashion industry, writing for leading magazines and websites. She’s tested and reviewed countless types of shoes, so that your feet may feel less pain than hers, and your closet is stocked with the most stylish and comfortable pairs.
Related Stories
-
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-best-jeans-for-women-recirc-84447c6b678141ac8b25c8a1bd83d756.jpg)
These Are the 12 Best Jeans for Women, Recommended After Testing 50+ Pairs -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/the-best-watches-for-women-tout-7846bdb13f4b4d03b1609eeea7796107.jpg)
The 18 Best Watches for Women for Every Budget and Occasion -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-best-swimsuits-for-long-torsos-tout-2-Recirc-5dd07183fd524a6daf73af75d61f9cd6.jpg)
The 16 Best Swimsuits for Long Torsos That Promise Zero Wedgies -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/the-best-baggy-jeans-tout-Recirc-b9580bdab4234e8db9c8445d37ac7436.jpg)
The 7 Best Baggy Jeans, Tested and Approved by Our Stylish Shopping Editors -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-jcrew-pdw-sale-tout-9b0b332cab8846bf82e61c0401e2ec27.jpg)
J.Crew’s Presidents’ Day Sale Has Leg-Elongating Jeans, Cashmere Cardigans, and Suede Bags Up to 77% Off -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-best-cotton-leggings-tout-52ab1383b1c143fc87515e45807d9762.jpg)
The 12 Best Cotton Leggings for Every Style, Body, and Budget -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/the-best-waterproof-mascaras-tout-Recirc-4ad4677f553a4ad88f32f3d78b3cb0dc.jpg)
These 8 Waterproof Mascaras Withstand Humidity, Sweat, and Tears, According to Testers -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-hoka-bondi-9-wearing-ashley-smith-8-comp-b6a7a36120fe4df8afaaa3e59e13e571.jpeg)
The 12 Best Sneakers for Wide Feet That Don’t Sacrifice Style
-
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-pilates-tout-f683c7d83b094fcea444ffb31bb86680.jpg)
I Go to Hot Pilates Weekly—Here’s What Everyone’s Wearing to Class, Starting at Just $10 -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-best-wool-coats-tout-2-80427236d3db48489b6e2bd88c0207f3.jpg)
We Found the 12 Best Wool Coats That Actually Keep Us Warm -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-eyeliner-tout-Recirc-236ff8afac894e1a9ac7ecc9b353adc1.jpg)
I’m a Picky Beauty Editor—These Are the 9 Best Liquid Eyeliners That Won’t Budge -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/the-best-foundations-tout-Recirc-df443aae055b4536ab43c5e39c9ae3ce.jpg)
The 10 Best Foundations for All Skin Tones and Skin Types, Approved by Testers -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/the-best-makeup-for-mature-skin-tout-Recirc-d0275914975c4b97a1b918229332e0fe.jpg)
Makeup Artists Agree: These Are the 12 Best Makeup Products for Mature Skin -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-cleansing-balms-tout-recirc-2d1eeafaabe541c285f0e53fa78a37ca.jpg)
After Testing Dozens, We Can Confidently Say These Are the 6 Best Cleansing Balms -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/the-best-teeth-whitening-products-tout-Recirc-936ba9d29fd440a085f6f53eebe0037a.jpg)
The 6 Best Teeth Whitening Products We Tested That Actually Work on Surface Stains -
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/byr-best-cream-eyeshadows-tout-recirc-1-0e17e80ec1314987b38241b2f5cdbd92.jpg)
The 13 Best Cream Eyeshadows for Crease-Free Looks, Approved by Testers
We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.
I Was a Loafer Skeptic, but These 12 Classic, Ultra-Comfortable Styles Won Me Over
I finally get the hype.
Byrdie
TL;DR
If you’re going to add one loafer to your collection, we recommend J.Crew’s Winona Penny Loafer. We were able to wear this loafer right out of the box without blisters, and the classic design goes with everything. If you prefer a loafer with a bit more edge, check out Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers. They are a platform loafer that doesn’t feel too bulky, and they come in fun colors like cow print, in addition to black and brown.
Believe me—it was going to take a lot to pry the white sneaker off my feet. I once believed it was the ultimate pair-all shoe, the only one capable of going with everything, from baggy jeans to sleek slips. That was until the loafer made its way into my life. Now I understand how a structured shoe—one that is both sleek and timeless—can feel sharp in style but comfortable in wear. Whether trekking to the train for a work commute or heading straight to cocktail hour, these celebrity-endorsed shoes truly can do it all.
After testing several pairs of loafers, I’m hooked, just like so many of our editors. If you’re wondering which pairs are truly worth making room for in your own closet, read on to shop the best loafers for women that we tested in our daily lives and fell in love with—with no blisters in sight.
Top Picks
J.Crew Penny Loafer at Jcrew.com$198
Jump to Review
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers at Amazon$165$99
Jump to Review
Favorite Daughter Loafer at Nordstrom$265
Jump to Review
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers at Revolve$275
Jump to Review
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer at Amazon$178
Jump to Review
Mango Penny Loafers at Mango.com$140
Jump to Review
Quince Horsebit Loafer at Quince$70
Jump to Review
Larroudé Loafer at Larroude.com$375
Jump to Review
Sezane Loafers at Sezane.com$230
Jump to Review
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer at Anntaylor.com$158$58
Jump to Review
Best Overall
J.Crew Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 3
This was the first pair that I tried, and they were like the unicorn of pennies. That’s because—to put it quite simply—I couldn’t find anything wrong with them. It’s a pair that keeps a flatteringly low profile, devoid of any fussy accents. Right out of the box, this pair had a rich leather scent. But what really converted me, and made me finally forgo my ballets for work commutes, was that I could walk four miles to and from my office without a single blister in sight. But compliments from strangers were plenty.
Best Chunky
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic outsole | Size Range: 5-15 | Colors: 4
A chunky style is like the cooler older sister of the loafer world. It gives a bit of edge, without straying too far from its origins. But for those who think they’re too punk rock for their wardrobe, let us introduce you to an easygoing version that proves a platform can be worn every day. We tested these while going for quick meetups and coffee runs and quickly realized they’re exceptional for long walks, too. That’s because there’s a substantial amount of weight on them—great for wintery outings—all without feeling too dense or bulky.
Ali Webb, associate style editor: “The design is so comfortable. They didn’t require any break-in time, and modern details like a chunky sole and a crinkled patent finish (or statement hues, if you choose) ensure that this is not your grandparents’ preppy shoe.”
Best for Work
Favorite Daughter Loafer
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic lining, rubber sole | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
A classically cool loafer, crafted by Favorite Daughter (yes—the sisters who also created the Byrdie-obsessed show Nobody Wants This), is the ideal mix of relaxed and collegiate. Associate Editor Emily Cieslak tested these and said they were easy to break in, but the real sell is in the color: a gorgeous burgundy croc, for when you want something that feels more luxe than black or brown. Sport these with cashmere sweaters and trousers or even a pair of slouchy jeans, if you want more of a juxtaposed look.
Emily Cieslak, associate editor: “I think these loafers are a great intro to the style for anyone hesitant to try. Think of them like your favorite ballet flats, but with a bit more edge.”
Most Comfortable
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers
Materials: Cow Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
If you’re looking for a loafer with soft, supple leather, these are it. When we tried this pair, equipped with ruching around the almond toe, we immediately felt the impact of trading in a stiff, synthetic shoe for one made of high-quality material. Not only is the look very Scandi—thanks to its buttery, worn-in leather and soft sheen—but our tester said she couldn’t believe a loafer could be so comfortable (there was no poking or rubbing at the ankles).Plus, the tiny heel (about 10 millimeters) gives this minimalist pair an elevated feel—literally.
Maddie Barber, writer: “[These are] STUNNING—such incredible quality, made with supple, soft leather.”
Best Penny Loafer
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: Black
A true no-brainer investment, these Madewell penny loafers take our top spot thanks to their smooth, sleek leather construction and sophisticated silhouette. They read high-end at first glance but deliver where it actually matters: comfort. Rarely does a brand-new shoe feel broken in on day one, yet Byrdie’s Editorial Director Holly Rhue was pleasantly surprised to find these blissfully ache- and blister-free straight out of the box. And aside from those sturdy leather uppers, these feature a faux penny—a refined yet nostalgic touch.
Holly Rhue, editorial director: “In terms of chunk factor, these are the Goldilocks of loafers. They’re not so flat that I can feel every grain of gravel under the sole, nor are they so chunky that I feel like I’m in lug soles.”
Best Suede
Mango Penny Loafers
Materials: Bovine leather | Size Range: 5-10 | Colors: 1
Without wavering too much into boat-shoe territory, these suede pennies from Mango keep things unfussy and casual, while still reading as a loafer. They bring just the right amount of texture and warmth to an outfit, especially in the winter when I just want something that feels easy on cold mornings but appears refined. While I’m glad to have this shoe’s full-grain counterpart in my closet, I adored how effortlessly these broke in because of the flexible vamps.
Best Backless
Quince Horsebit Loafer
Materials: Italian calf leather upper| Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
In case you haven’t heard, the backless loafer is back, and this is one 2016 trend we’re happy to revive without cringing. Truly a business-in-the-front, easy-going-in-the-back shoe, these loafers are structured like an open-backed mule, but appear to be a classic flat at the toe. They immediately reminded me of the iconic Gucci Princetown loafers when I unboxed them, but with an enticing under-$100 price tag. I loved the gorgeous mocha color, which is rich enough to sub in for when your classic black pair feels a bit drab.
Best Designer
Larroudé Loafer
Materials: Luster calf leather | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
Sometimes, a shoe costs a pretty penny—pun fully intended—and you quickly realize it’s not functional whatsoever. What I love about Larroudé, though, is that they’re quite reliable and even more stylish. These are the rare shoes that look like they should hurt but don’t. The low, flat sole is rubberized for comfort and grip, the classic loafer silhouette keeps them wearable, and a thinly laid gold ornament adds just the right amount of polish to an everyday flat.
Best for Wide Feet
Sezane Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 4-11 | Colors: 2
For us wider-footed girlies, Sézane has made a platformed leather with a wider fit that gives height without being aggressively chunky. I loved pairing these with baggy proportions, since they reinforce the relaxed, oversized feel. The rubber outsole keeps these durable (I wore them on a very rainy day, and honestly didn’t miss my rain boots at all—the same can’t be said for my Oxfords or ballet flats). They feel genuinely tactile underfoot, yet still read feminine to onlookers as I hustled through the streets of Manhattan.
Best Animal Print
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer
Materials: Suede | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
For those of us who believe leopard is neutral, this playful pair from Ann Taylor is a wonderful way to incorporate animal print into your footwear. Made from 100% suede, this classic loafer is on the cheaper side for shoes made from the same materials. We love that, of course—but we also love the detailing at the front of this shoe that adds a textural flair.
Best Brown
M.Gemi The Brenda
Materials: Italian kid suede upper with nappa leather details, Italian leather lining | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
M.Gemi knows how to make an investment piece, like these biscuit-colored beauties, which are also available in a chocolate-y brown and—the colorway I’ve been eyeing—a gorgeous and funky snakeskin. The standout feature of these otherwise low-profile loafers is the soft leather twisted, tubular bands that adorn the toebox. They’re also made with a Sacchetto suede (something I, admittedly, had to Google, which is an Italian, hand-stitched technique where the lining and insole are sewn together like a “little bag”). And that kind of craftsmanship shines through, as they feel and look high-end, though I would note that they probably do work best for narrower feet, as the quarters were on the tighter end.
Best Casual
Cos Leather Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 6-12 | Colors: 1
For a shoe that looks (and feels!) more like a slipper, that even the most unconvinced loafer skeptic could find themselves in, enter the Cos leather loafer. As a shoe that could be mistaken for something by The Row, these pared-down, minimalist loafers beg the question: Why wear anything else when they are as refined as an Oxford shoe but as comfortable as indoor footwear? Our tester asked herself the same question, noting how comfortable they were and how the materials felt, likely due to the 100% leather, which made for a breathable, natural interior and a flexible sole.
Shannon Stubbs, writer: “I’m not really a fan of loafers, so it was hard to find a pair that fit my style. The soft leather gives them a casual, understated vibe that I think standard loafers don’t have.”
What to Look for in Loafers for Women
- Materials: When it comes to loafers, real leather remains the gold standard: it softens over time, molds to your foot, and can last for years with proper care (AKA resoling and conditioning). Faux or “vegan” leather tends to be more affordable but can stay rigid and often cracks or peels rather than aging gracefully. Liz Teich, a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist, tells Byrdie that most vegan leathers are made from plastic, meaning they won’t biodegrade and rarely hold up long-term. So if you’re looking for a more sustainable option: Go real.
- Texture: Some textures our experts are loving, and recommend for your closet:
- Smooth leatheris both timeless and long-lasting, adds Teich. It’s easiest to maintain, and it’s the most versatile.
- Pebbled leather feels softer right out of the box and is more forgiving of scuffs.
- Suede (think camel or chocolate) adds warmth and richness, but save it for your second or third pair—and always spray with protectant, warns Teich.
- Pony hair brings texture without shouting, and it’s perfect for neutral dressers craving something a tad bit more memorable.
- Fit:Lauren Sharkey, a Chicago-based personal stylist, notes that most blister complaints come from too much room, especially at the heel. If you can slip your heel out without using your hands, expect rubbing. Experts recommend sticking close to your true size and erring slightly on the snug. That’s because leather stretches with wear and warmth. “I’d recommend sizing to the foot, not the sock—instead opt for a thin (ideally cashmere) sock that adds the most minimal padding to your foot,” says Sharkey. “I prefer this aesthetically as well,”
- Color: If you’re just starting to build your loafer collection, Sharkey recommends a low-profile, no-hardware black loafer. “From there, I’d prioritize a rich caramel or chocolate suede pair that delivers depth, texture, and warmth to a look. And I’d round it out with a high gloss black patent loafer for a statement finish,” says Sharkey. “If you tend to wear mostly neutrals, like myself and my clients, a deep bordeaux or burgundy is a lovely addition — again, not your first pair but an additive pair. They punctuate a tonal look, from rich browns to cool heather grays or blacks. They also soften a denim-on-denim look.”
How We Tested Loafers for Women
Byrdie
Byrdie editors and writers tested multiple pairs of loafers for a month. Each of us looked for the things you actually care about when shopping for the best pair of shoes: comfort, durability (we did a lot of walking, long commutes, and serious breaking in), quality of materials, and how long they took to soften up. And, transparently, if a pair tore up our ankles, it didn’t make the list.
Meet Our Experts
For this article, we interviewed several stylists for advice on how to shop for and style loafers.
- Joy Asibey-Gabriel is a personal stylist and feminine adornment coach.
- Lauren Sharkey is a Chicago-based personal stylist.
- Liz Teich is a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist.
Why Trust Byrdie
Byrdie contributor Morgan Sullivan has over half a decade of experience in the beauty and fashion industry, writing for leading magazines and websites. She’s tested and reviewed countless types of shoes, so that your feet may feel less pain than hers, and your closet is stocked with the most stylish and comfortable pairs.
Byrdie
TL;DR
If you’re going to add one loafer to your collection, we recommend J.Crew’s Winona Penny Loafer. We were able to wear this loafer right out of the box without blisters, and the classic design goes with everything. If you prefer a loafer with a bit more edge, check out Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers. They are a platform loafer that doesn’t feel too bulky, and they come in fun colors like cow print, in addition to black and brown.
Believe me—it was going to take a lot to pry the white sneaker off my feet. I once believed it was the ultimate pair-all shoe, the only one capable of going with everything, from baggy jeans to sleek slips. That was until the loafer made its way into my life. Now I understand how a structured shoe—one that is both sleek and timeless—can feel sharp in style but comfortable in wear. Whether trekking to the train for a work commute or heading straight to cocktail hour, these celebrity-endorsed shoes truly can do it all.
After testing several pairs of loafers, I’m hooked, just like so many of our editors. If you’re wondering which pairs are truly worth making room for in your own closet, read on to shop the best loafers for women that we tested in our daily lives and fell in love with—with no blisters in sight.
Top Picks
J.Crew Penny Loafer at Jcrew.com$198
Jump to Review
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers at Amazon$165$99
Jump to Review
Favorite Daughter Loafer at Nordstrom$265
Jump to Review
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers at Revolve$275
Jump to Review
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer at Amazon$178
Jump to Review
Mango Penny Loafers at Mango.com$140
Jump to Review
Quince Horsebit Loafer at Quince$70
Jump to Review
Larroudé Loafer at Larroude.com$375
Jump to Review
Sezane Loafers at Sezane.com$230
Jump to Review
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer at Anntaylor.com$158$58
Jump to Review
Best Overall
J.Crew Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 3
This was the first pair that I tried, and they were like the unicorn of pennies. That’s because—to put it quite simply—I couldn’t find anything wrong with them. It’s a pair that keeps a flatteringly low profile, devoid of any fussy accents. Right out of the box, this pair had a rich leather scent. But what really converted me, and made me finally forgo my ballets for work commutes, was that I could walk four miles to and from my office without a single blister in sight. But compliments from strangers were plenty.
Best Chunky
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic outsole | Size Range: 5-15 | Colors: 4
A chunky style is like the cooler older sister of the loafer world. It gives a bit of edge, without straying too far from its origins. But for those who think they’re too punk rock for their wardrobe, let us introduce you to an easygoing version that proves a platform can be worn every day. We tested these while going for quick meetups and coffee runs and quickly realized they’re exceptional for long walks, too. That’s because there’s a substantial amount of weight on them—great for wintery outings—all without feeling too dense or bulky.
Ali Webb, associate style editor: “The design is so comfortable. They didn’t require any break-in time, and modern details like a chunky sole and a crinkled patent finish (or statement hues, if you choose) ensure that this is not your grandparents’ preppy shoe.”
Best for Work
Favorite Daughter Loafer
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic lining, rubber sole | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
A classically cool loafer, crafted by Favorite Daughter (yes—the sisters who also created the Byrdie-obsessed show Nobody Wants This), is the ideal mix of relaxed and collegiate. Associate Editor Emily Cieslak tested these and said they were easy to break in, but the real sell is in the color: a gorgeous burgundy croc, for when you want something that feels more luxe than black or brown. Sport these with cashmere sweaters and trousers or even a pair of slouchy jeans, if you want more of a juxtaposed look.
Emily Cieslak, associate editor: “I think these loafers are a great intro to the style for anyone hesitant to try. Think of them like your favorite ballet flats, but with a bit more edge.”
Most Comfortable
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers
Materials: Cow Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
If you’re looking for a loafer with soft, supple leather, these are it. When we tried this pair, equipped with ruching around the almond toe, we immediately felt the impact of trading in a stiff, synthetic shoe for one made of high-quality material. Not only is the look very Scandi—thanks to its buttery, worn-in leather and soft sheen—but our tester said she couldn’t believe a loafer could be so comfortable (there was no poking or rubbing at the ankles).Plus, the tiny heel (about 10 millimeters) gives this minimalist pair an elevated feel—literally.
Maddie Barber, writer: “[These are] STUNNING—such incredible quality, made with supple, soft leather.”
Best Penny Loafer
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: Black
A true no-brainer investment, these Madewell penny loafers take our top spot thanks to their smooth, sleek leather construction and sophisticated silhouette. They read high-end at first glance but deliver where it actually matters: comfort. Rarely does a brand-new shoe feel broken in on day one, yet Byrdie’s Editorial Director Holly Rhue was pleasantly surprised to find these blissfully ache- and blister-free straight out of the box. And aside from those sturdy leather uppers, these feature a faux penny—a refined yet nostalgic touch.
Holly Rhue, editorial director: “In terms of chunk factor, these are the Goldilocks of loafers. They’re not so flat that I can feel every grain of gravel under the sole, nor are they so chunky that I feel like I’m in lug soles.”
Best Suede
Mango Penny Loafers
Materials: Bovine leather | Size Range: 5-10 | Colors: 1
Without wavering too much into boat-shoe territory, these suede pennies from Mango keep things unfussy and casual, while still reading as a loafer. They bring just the right amount of texture and warmth to an outfit, especially in the winter when I just want something that feels easy on cold mornings but appears refined. While I’m glad to have this shoe’s full-grain counterpart in my closet, I adored how effortlessly these broke in because of the flexible vamps.
Best Backless
Quince Horsebit Loafer
Materials: Italian calf leather upper| Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
In case you haven’t heard, the backless loafer is back, and this is one 2016 trend we’re happy to revive without cringing. Truly a business-in-the-front, easy-going-in-the-back shoe, these loafers are structured like an open-backed mule, but appear to be a classic flat at the toe. They immediately reminded me of the iconic Gucci Princetown loafers when I unboxed them, but with an enticing under-$100 price tag. I loved the gorgeous mocha color, which is rich enough to sub in for when your classic black pair feels a bit drab.
Best Designer
Larroudé Loafer
Materials: Luster calf leather | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
Sometimes, a shoe costs a pretty penny—pun fully intended—and you quickly realize it’s not functional whatsoever. What I love about Larroudé, though, is that they’re quite reliable and even more stylish. These are the rare shoes that look like they should hurt but don’t. The low, flat sole is rubberized for comfort and grip, the classic loafer silhouette keeps them wearable, and a thinly laid gold ornament adds just the right amount of polish to an everyday flat.
Best for Wide Feet
Sezane Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 4-11 | Colors: 2
For us wider-footed girlies, Sézane has made a platformed leather with a wider fit that gives height without being aggressively chunky. I loved pairing these with baggy proportions, since they reinforce the relaxed, oversized feel. The rubber outsole keeps these durable (I wore them on a very rainy day, and honestly didn’t miss my rain boots at all—the same can’t be said for my Oxfords or ballet flats). They feel genuinely tactile underfoot, yet still read feminine to onlookers as I hustled through the streets of Manhattan.
Best Animal Print
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer
Materials: Suede | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
For those of us who believe leopard is neutral, this playful pair from Ann Taylor is a wonderful way to incorporate animal print into your footwear. Made from 100% suede, this classic loafer is on the cheaper side for shoes made from the same materials. We love that, of course—but we also love the detailing at the front of this shoe that adds a textural flair.
Best Brown
M.Gemi The Brenda
Materials: Italian kid suede upper with nappa leather details, Italian leather lining | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
M.Gemi knows how to make an investment piece, like these biscuit-colored beauties, which are also available in a chocolate-y brown and—the colorway I’ve been eyeing—a gorgeous and funky snakeskin. The standout feature of these otherwise low-profile loafers is the soft leather twisted, tubular bands that adorn the toebox. They’re also made with a Sacchetto suede (something I, admittedly, had to Google, which is an Italian, hand-stitched technique where the lining and insole are sewn together like a “little bag”). And that kind of craftsmanship shines through, as they feel and look high-end, though I would note that they probably do work best for narrower feet, as the quarters were on the tighter end.
Best Casual
Cos Leather Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 6-12 | Colors: 1
For a shoe that looks (and feels!) more like a slipper, that even the most unconvinced loafer skeptic could find themselves in, enter the Cos leather loafer. As a shoe that could be mistaken for something by The Row, these pared-down, minimalist loafers beg the question: Why wear anything else when they are as refined as an Oxford shoe but as comfortable as indoor footwear? Our tester asked herself the same question, noting how comfortable they were and how the materials felt, likely due to the 100% leather, which made for a breathable, natural interior and a flexible sole.
Shannon Stubbs, writer: “I’m not really a fan of loafers, so it was hard to find a pair that fit my style. The soft leather gives them a casual, understated vibe that I think standard loafers don’t have.”
What to Look for in Loafers for Women
- Materials: When it comes to loafers, real leather remains the gold standard: it softens over time, molds to your foot, and can last for years with proper care (AKA resoling and conditioning). Faux or “vegan” leather tends to be more affordable but can stay rigid and often cracks or peels rather than aging gracefully. Liz Teich, a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist, tells Byrdie that most vegan leathers are made from plastic, meaning they won’t biodegrade and rarely hold up long-term. So if you’re looking for a more sustainable option: Go real.
- Texture: Some textures our experts are loving, and recommend for your closet:
- Smooth leatheris both timeless and long-lasting, adds Teich. It’s easiest to maintain, and it’s the most versatile.
- Pebbled leather feels softer right out of the box and is more forgiving of scuffs.
- Suede (think camel or chocolate) adds warmth and richness, but save it for your second or third pair—and always spray with protectant, warns Teich.
- Pony hair brings texture without shouting, and it’s perfect for neutral dressers craving something a tad bit more memorable.
- Fit:Lauren Sharkey, a Chicago-based personal stylist, notes that most blister complaints come from too much room, especially at the heel. If you can slip your heel out without using your hands, expect rubbing. Experts recommend sticking close to your true size and erring slightly on the snug. That’s because leather stretches with wear and warmth. “I’d recommend sizing to the foot, not the sock—instead opt for a thin (ideally cashmere) sock that adds the most minimal padding to your foot,” says Sharkey. “I prefer this aesthetically as well,”
- Color: If you’re just starting to build your loafer collection, Sharkey recommends a low-profile, no-hardware black loafer. “From there, I’d prioritize a rich caramel or chocolate suede pair that delivers depth, texture, and warmth to a look. And I’d round it out with a high gloss black patent loafer for a statement finish,” says Sharkey. “If you tend to wear mostly neutrals, like myself and my clients, a deep bordeaux or burgundy is a lovely addition — again, not your first pair but an additive pair. They punctuate a tonal look, from rich browns to cool heather grays or blacks. They also soften a denim-on-denim look.”
How We Tested Loafers for Women
Byrdie
Byrdie editors and writers tested multiple pairs of loafers for a month. Each of us looked for the things you actually care about when shopping for the best pair of shoes: comfort, durability (we did a lot of walking, long commutes, and serious breaking in), quality of materials, and how long they took to soften up. And, transparently, if a pair tore up our ankles, it didn’t make the list.
Meet Our Experts
For this article, we interviewed several stylists for advice on how to shop for and style loafers.
- Joy Asibey-Gabriel is a personal stylist and feminine adornment coach.
- Lauren Sharkey is a Chicago-based personal stylist.
- Liz Teich is a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist.
Why Trust Byrdie
Byrdie contributor Morgan Sullivan has over half a decade of experience in the beauty and fashion industry, writing for leading magazines and websites. She’s tested and reviewed countless types of shoes, so that your feet may feel less pain than hers, and your closet is stocked with the most stylish and comfortable pairs.
TL;DR
If you’re going to add one loafer to your collection, we recommend J.Crew’s Winona Penny Loafer. We were able to wear this loafer right out of the box without blisters, and the classic design goes with everything. If you prefer a loafer with a bit more edge, check out Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers. They are a platform loafer that doesn’t feel too bulky, and they come in fun colors like cow print, in addition to black and brown.
Believe me—it was going to take a lot to pry the white sneaker off my feet. I once believed it was the ultimate pair-all shoe, the only one capable of going with everything, from baggy jeans to sleek slips. That was until the loafer made its way into my life. Now I understand how a structured shoe—one that is both sleek and timeless—can feel sharp in style but comfortable in wear. Whether trekking to the train for a work commute or heading straight to cocktail hour, these celebrity-endorsed shoes truly can do it all.
After testing several pairs of loafers, I’m hooked, just like so many of our editors. If you’re wondering which pairs are truly worth making room for in your own closet, read on to shop the best loafers for women that we tested in our daily lives and fell in love with—with no blisters in sight.
Top Picks
J.Crew Penny Loafer at Jcrew.com$198
Jump to Review
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers at Amazon$165$99
Jump to Review
Favorite Daughter Loafer at Nordstrom$265
Jump to Review
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers at Revolve$275
Jump to Review
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer at Amazon$178
Jump to Review
Mango Penny Loafers at Mango.com$140
Jump to Review
Quince Horsebit Loafer at Quince$70
Jump to Review
Larroudé Loafer at Larroude.com$375
Jump to Review
Sezane Loafers at Sezane.com$230
Jump to Review
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer at Anntaylor.com$158$58
Jump to Review
Best Overall
J.Crew Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 3
This was the first pair that I tried, and they were like the unicorn of pennies. That’s because—to put it quite simply—I couldn’t find anything wrong with them. It’s a pair that keeps a flatteringly low profile, devoid of any fussy accents. Right out of the box, this pair had a rich leather scent. But what really converted me, and made me finally forgo my ballets for work commutes, was that I could walk four miles to and from my office without a single blister in sight. But compliments from strangers were plenty.
Best Chunky
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic outsole | Size Range: 5-15 | Colors: 4
A chunky style is like the cooler older sister of the loafer world. It gives a bit of edge, without straying too far from its origins. But for those who think they’re too punk rock for their wardrobe, let us introduce you to an easygoing version that proves a platform can be worn every day. We tested these while going for quick meetups and coffee runs and quickly realized they’re exceptional for long walks, too. That’s because there’s a substantial amount of weight on them—great for wintery outings—all without feeling too dense or bulky.
Ali Webb, associate style editor: “The design is so comfortable. They didn’t require any break-in time, and modern details like a chunky sole and a crinkled patent finish (or statement hues, if you choose) ensure that this is not your grandparents’ preppy shoe.”
Best for Work
Favorite Daughter Loafer
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic lining, rubber sole | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
A classically cool loafer, crafted by Favorite Daughter (yes—the sisters who also created the Byrdie-obsessed show Nobody Wants This), is the ideal mix of relaxed and collegiate. Associate Editor Emily Cieslak tested these and said they were easy to break in, but the real sell is in the color: a gorgeous burgundy croc, for when you want something that feels more luxe than black or brown. Sport these with cashmere sweaters and trousers or even a pair of slouchy jeans, if you want more of a juxtaposed look.
Emily Cieslak, associate editor: “I think these loafers are a great intro to the style for anyone hesitant to try. Think of them like your favorite ballet flats, but with a bit more edge.”
Most Comfortable
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers
Materials: Cow Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
If you’re looking for a loafer with soft, supple leather, these are it. When we tried this pair, equipped with ruching around the almond toe, we immediately felt the impact of trading in a stiff, synthetic shoe for one made of high-quality material. Not only is the look very Scandi—thanks to its buttery, worn-in leather and soft sheen—but our tester said she couldn’t believe a loafer could be so comfortable (there was no poking or rubbing at the ankles).Plus, the tiny heel (about 10 millimeters) gives this minimalist pair an elevated feel—literally.
Maddie Barber, writer: “[These are] STUNNING—such incredible quality, made with supple, soft leather.”
Best Penny Loafer
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: Black
A true no-brainer investment, these Madewell penny loafers take our top spot thanks to their smooth, sleek leather construction and sophisticated silhouette. They read high-end at first glance but deliver where it actually matters: comfort. Rarely does a brand-new shoe feel broken in on day one, yet Byrdie’s Editorial Director Holly Rhue was pleasantly surprised to find these blissfully ache- and blister-free straight out of the box. And aside from those sturdy leather uppers, these feature a faux penny—a refined yet nostalgic touch.
Holly Rhue, editorial director: “In terms of chunk factor, these are the Goldilocks of loafers. They’re not so flat that I can feel every grain of gravel under the sole, nor are they so chunky that I feel like I’m in lug soles.”
Best Suede
Mango Penny Loafers
Materials: Bovine leather | Size Range: 5-10 | Colors: 1
Without wavering too much into boat-shoe territory, these suede pennies from Mango keep things unfussy and casual, while still reading as a loafer. They bring just the right amount of texture and warmth to an outfit, especially in the winter when I just want something that feels easy on cold mornings but appears refined. While I’m glad to have this shoe’s full-grain counterpart in my closet, I adored how effortlessly these broke in because of the flexible vamps.
Best Backless
Quince Horsebit Loafer
Materials: Italian calf leather upper| Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
In case you haven’t heard, the backless loafer is back, and this is one 2016 trend we’re happy to revive without cringing. Truly a business-in-the-front, easy-going-in-the-back shoe, these loafers are structured like an open-backed mule, but appear to be a classic flat at the toe. They immediately reminded me of the iconic Gucci Princetown loafers when I unboxed them, but with an enticing under-$100 price tag. I loved the gorgeous mocha color, which is rich enough to sub in for when your classic black pair feels a bit drab.
Best Designer
Larroudé Loafer
Materials: Luster calf leather | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
Sometimes, a shoe costs a pretty penny—pun fully intended—and you quickly realize it’s not functional whatsoever. What I love about Larroudé, though, is that they’re quite reliable and even more stylish. These are the rare shoes that look like they should hurt but don’t. The low, flat sole is rubberized for comfort and grip, the classic loafer silhouette keeps them wearable, and a thinly laid gold ornament adds just the right amount of polish to an everyday flat.
Best for Wide Feet
Sezane Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 4-11 | Colors: 2
For us wider-footed girlies, Sézane has made a platformed leather with a wider fit that gives height without being aggressively chunky. I loved pairing these with baggy proportions, since they reinforce the relaxed, oversized feel. The rubber outsole keeps these durable (I wore them on a very rainy day, and honestly didn’t miss my rain boots at all—the same can’t be said for my Oxfords or ballet flats). They feel genuinely tactile underfoot, yet still read feminine to onlookers as I hustled through the streets of Manhattan.
Best Animal Print
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer
Materials: Suede | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
For those of us who believe leopard is neutral, this playful pair from Ann Taylor is a wonderful way to incorporate animal print into your footwear. Made from 100% suede, this classic loafer is on the cheaper side for shoes made from the same materials. We love that, of course—but we also love the detailing at the front of this shoe that adds a textural flair.
Best Brown
M.Gemi The Brenda
Materials: Italian kid suede upper with nappa leather details, Italian leather lining | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
M.Gemi knows how to make an investment piece, like these biscuit-colored beauties, which are also available in a chocolate-y brown and—the colorway I’ve been eyeing—a gorgeous and funky snakeskin. The standout feature of these otherwise low-profile loafers is the soft leather twisted, tubular bands that adorn the toebox. They’re also made with a Sacchetto suede (something I, admittedly, had to Google, which is an Italian, hand-stitched technique where the lining and insole are sewn together like a “little bag”). And that kind of craftsmanship shines through, as they feel and look high-end, though I would note that they probably do work best for narrower feet, as the quarters were on the tighter end.
Best Casual
Cos Leather Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 6-12 | Colors: 1
For a shoe that looks (and feels!) more like a slipper, that even the most unconvinced loafer skeptic could find themselves in, enter the Cos leather loafer. As a shoe that could be mistaken for something by The Row, these pared-down, minimalist loafers beg the question: Why wear anything else when they are as refined as an Oxford shoe but as comfortable as indoor footwear? Our tester asked herself the same question, noting how comfortable they were and how the materials felt, likely due to the 100% leather, which made for a breathable, natural interior and a flexible sole.
Shannon Stubbs, writer: “I’m not really a fan of loafers, so it was hard to find a pair that fit my style. The soft leather gives them a casual, understated vibe that I think standard loafers don’t have.”
What to Look for in Loafers for Women
- Materials: When it comes to loafers, real leather remains the gold standard: it softens over time, molds to your foot, and can last for years with proper care (AKA resoling and conditioning). Faux or “vegan” leather tends to be more affordable but can stay rigid and often cracks or peels rather than aging gracefully. Liz Teich, a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist, tells Byrdie that most vegan leathers are made from plastic, meaning they won’t biodegrade and rarely hold up long-term. So if you’re looking for a more sustainable option: Go real.
- Texture: Some textures our experts are loving, and recommend for your closet:
- Smooth leatheris both timeless and long-lasting, adds Teich. It’s easiest to maintain, and it’s the most versatile.
- Pebbled leather feels softer right out of the box and is more forgiving of scuffs.
- Suede (think camel or chocolate) adds warmth and richness, but save it for your second or third pair—and always spray with protectant, warns Teich.
- Pony hair brings texture without shouting, and it’s perfect for neutral dressers craving something a tad bit more memorable.
- Fit:Lauren Sharkey, a Chicago-based personal stylist, notes that most blister complaints come from too much room, especially at the heel. If you can slip your heel out without using your hands, expect rubbing. Experts recommend sticking close to your true size and erring slightly on the snug. That’s because leather stretches with wear and warmth. “I’d recommend sizing to the foot, not the sock—instead opt for a thin (ideally cashmere) sock that adds the most minimal padding to your foot,” says Sharkey. “I prefer this aesthetically as well,”
- Color: If you’re just starting to build your loafer collection, Sharkey recommends a low-profile, no-hardware black loafer. “From there, I’d prioritize a rich caramel or chocolate suede pair that delivers depth, texture, and warmth to a look. And I’d round it out with a high gloss black patent loafer for a statement finish,” says Sharkey. “If you tend to wear mostly neutrals, like myself and my clients, a deep bordeaux or burgundy is a lovely addition — again, not your first pair but an additive pair. They punctuate a tonal look, from rich browns to cool heather grays or blacks. They also soften a denim-on-denim look.”
How We Tested Loafers for Women
Byrdie
Byrdie editors and writers tested multiple pairs of loafers for a month. Each of us looked for the things you actually care about when shopping for the best pair of shoes: comfort, durability (we did a lot of walking, long commutes, and serious breaking in), quality of materials, and how long they took to soften up. And, transparently, if a pair tore up our ankles, it didn’t make the list.
Meet Our Experts
For this article, we interviewed several stylists for advice on how to shop for and style loafers.
- Joy Asibey-Gabriel is a personal stylist and feminine adornment coach.
- Lauren Sharkey is a Chicago-based personal stylist.
- Liz Teich is a New York-based personal stylist and creator of The New York Stylist.
Why Trust Byrdie
Byrdie contributor Morgan Sullivan has over half a decade of experience in the beauty and fashion industry, writing for leading magazines and websites. She’s tested and reviewed countless types of shoes, so that your feet may feel less pain than hers, and your closet is stocked with the most stylish and comfortable pairs.
Best Overall
J.Crew Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 3
This was the first pair that I tried, and they were like the unicorn of pennies. That’s because—to put it quite simply—I couldn’t find anything wrong with them. It’s a pair that keeps a flatteringly low profile, devoid of any fussy accents. Right out of the box, this pair had a rich leather scent. But what really converted me, and made me finally forgo my ballets for work commutes, was that I could walk four miles to and from my office without a single blister in sight. But compliments from strangers were plenty.
Best Chunky
Dolce Vita Tiggy Loafers
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic outsole | Size Range: 5-15 | Colors: 4
A chunky style is like the cooler older sister of the loafer world. It gives a bit of edge, without straying too far from its origins. But for those who think they’re too punk rock for their wardrobe, let us introduce you to an easygoing version that proves a platform can be worn every day. We tested these while going for quick meetups and coffee runs and quickly realized they’re exceptional for long walks, too. That’s because there’s a substantial amount of weight on them—great for wintery outings—all without feeling too dense or bulky.
Ali Webb, associate style editor: “The design is so comfortable. They didn’t require any break-in time, and modern details like a chunky sole and a crinkled patent finish (or statement hues, if you choose) ensure that this is not your grandparents’ preppy shoe.”
Best for Work
Favorite Daughter Loafer
Materials: Leather upper, synthetic lining, rubber sole | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
A classically cool loafer, crafted by Favorite Daughter (yes—the sisters who also created the Byrdie-obsessed show Nobody Wants This), is the ideal mix of relaxed and collegiate. Associate Editor Emily Cieslak tested these and said they were easy to break in, but the real sell is in the color: a gorgeous burgundy croc, for when you want something that feels more luxe than black or brown. Sport these with cashmere sweaters and trousers or even a pair of slouchy jeans, if you want more of a juxtaposed look.
Emily Cieslak, associate editor: “I think these loafers are a great intro to the style for anyone hesitant to try. Think of them like your favorite ballet flats, but with a bit more edge.”
Most Comfortable
Flattered Bon Bon Leather Black Loafers
Materials: Cow Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
If you’re looking for a loafer with soft, supple leather, these are it. When we tried this pair, equipped with ruching around the almond toe, we immediately felt the impact of trading in a stiff, synthetic shoe for one made of high-quality material. Not only is the look very Scandi—thanks to its buttery, worn-in leather and soft sheen—but our tester said she couldn’t believe a loafer could be so comfortable (there was no poking or rubbing at the ankles).Plus, the tiny heel (about 10 millimeters) gives this minimalist pair an elevated feel—literally.
Maddie Barber, writer: “[These are] STUNNING—such incredible quality, made with supple, soft leather.”
Best Penny Loafer
Madewell The Grayson Penny Loafer
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: Black
A true no-brainer investment, these Madewell penny loafers take our top spot thanks to their smooth, sleek leather construction and sophisticated silhouette. They read high-end at first glance but deliver where it actually matters: comfort. Rarely does a brand-new shoe feel broken in on day one, yet Byrdie’s Editorial Director Holly Rhue was pleasantly surprised to find these blissfully ache- and blister-free straight out of the box. And aside from those sturdy leather uppers, these feature a faux penny—a refined yet nostalgic touch.
Holly Rhue, editorial director: “In terms of chunk factor, these are the Goldilocks of loafers. They’re not so flat that I can feel every grain of gravel under the sole, nor are they so chunky that I feel like I’m in lug soles.”
Best Suede
Mango Penny Loafers
Materials: Bovine leather | Size Range: 5-10 | Colors: 1
Without wavering too much into boat-shoe territory, these suede pennies from Mango keep things unfussy and casual, while still reading as a loafer. They bring just the right amount of texture and warmth to an outfit, especially in the winter when I just want something that feels easy on cold mornings but appears refined. While I’m glad to have this shoe’s full-grain counterpart in my closet, I adored how effortlessly these broke in because of the flexible vamps.
Best Backless
Quince Horsebit Loafer
Materials: Italian calf leather upper| Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 4
In case you haven’t heard, the backless loafer is back, and this is one 2016 trend we’re happy to revive without cringing. Truly a business-in-the-front, easy-going-in-the-back shoe, these loafers are structured like an open-backed mule, but appear to be a classic flat at the toe. They immediately reminded me of the iconic Gucci Princetown loafers when I unboxed them, but with an enticing under-$100 price tag. I loved the gorgeous mocha color, which is rich enough to sub in for when your classic black pair feels a bit drab.
Best Designer
Larroudé Loafer
Materials: Luster calf leather | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
Sometimes, a shoe costs a pretty penny—pun fully intended—and you quickly realize it’s not functional whatsoever. What I love about Larroudé, though, is that they’re quite reliable and even more stylish. These are the rare shoes that look like they should hurt but don’t. The low, flat sole is rubberized for comfort and grip, the classic loafer silhouette keeps them wearable, and a thinly laid gold ornament adds just the right amount of polish to an everyday flat.
Best for Wide Feet
Sezane Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 4-11 | Colors: 2
For us wider-footed girlies, Sézane has made a platformed leather with a wider fit that gives height without being aggressively chunky. I loved pairing these with baggy proportions, since they reinforce the relaxed, oversized feel. The rubber outsole keeps these durable (I wore them on a very rainy day, and honestly didn’t miss my rain boots at all—the same can’t be said for my Oxfords or ballet flats). They feel genuinely tactile underfoot, yet still read feminine to onlookers as I hustled through the streets of Manhattan.
Best Animal Print
Ann Taylor Suede Loafer
Materials: Suede | Size Range: 5-11 | Colors: 1
For those of us who believe leopard is neutral, this playful pair from Ann Taylor is a wonderful way to incorporate animal print into your footwear. Made from 100% suede, this classic loafer is on the cheaper side for shoes made from the same materials. We love that, of course—but we also love the detailing at the front of this shoe that adds a textural flair.
Best Brown
M.Gemi The Brenda
Materials: Italian kid suede upper with nappa leather details, Italian leather lining | Size Range: 5-12 | Colors: 5
M.Gemi knows how to make an investment piece, like these biscuit-colored beauties, which are also available in a chocolate-y brown and—the colorway I’ve been eyeing—a gorgeous and funky snakeskin. The standout feature of these otherwise low-profile loafers is the soft leather twisted, tubular bands that adorn the toebox. They’re also made with a Sacchetto suede (something I, admittedly, had to Google, which is an Italian, hand-stitched technique where the lining and insole are sewn together like a “little bag”). And that kind of craftsmanship shines through, as they feel and look high-end, though I would note that they probably do work best for narrower feet, as the quarters were on the tighter end.
Best Casual
Cos Leather Loafers
Materials: Leather | Size Range: 6-12 | Colors: 1
For a shoe that looks (and feels!) more like a slipper, that even the most unconvinced loafer skeptic could find themselves in, enter the Cos leather loafer. As a shoe that could be mistaken for something by The Row, these pared-down, minimalist loafers beg the question: Why wear anything else when they are as refined as an Oxford shoe but as comfortable as indoor footwear? Our tester asked herself the same question, noting how comfortable they were and how the materials felt, likely due to the 100% leather, which made for a breathable, natural interior and a flexible sole.
Shannon Stubbs, writer: “I’m not really a fan of loafers, so it was hard to find a pair that fit my style. The soft leather gives them a casual, understated vibe that I think standard loafers don’t have.”
[analyse_source url=”https://www.byrdie.com/best-loafers-for-women-11894537″]