Best Overall

Advanced Clinicals Retinol Advanced Firming Cream

$18 at Amazon$18 at IHerb$18 at Advancedclinicals.com

Ingredients: Retinol, green tea extract, vitamin E, aloe vera | Size: 16 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Retinol is a gold-standard anti-ager that’s commonly found in facial wrinkle creams. The vitamin A derivative is a standout for increasing cell turnover, leaving skin smoother and more even, while also boosting collagen production to combat wrinkles. Here, it’s combined with deeply hydrating aloe and vitamin E, alongside green tea, a potent antioxidant that further enhances this winner’s anti-aging effects. An easy-to-use pump-top dispenser, nongreasy texture, and affordable price tag are just the cherry (cherries?) on top of the sundae.

Best Drugstore

Jergens Skin Firming Body Lotion

$9

$8 at Amazon$8 at Target

$10

$9 at Walgreens

Ingredients: Collagen, elastin, shea oil, glycerin| Size: 16.8 oz | Fragrance-Free: No | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Believe it: You can find some great body lotions for mature skin at the drugstore. Exhibit A? This is a standout option from Jergens. It boasts anti-aging benefits, specifically collagen and elastin, two proteins essential for maintaining smooth, bouncy, youthful skin. It also imparts plenty of hydration with glycerin, which helps attract water to the skin, petrolatum, which seals that moisture in, and shea oil, leaving you feeling silky smooth from head to toe. While it’s not fragrance-free (a drawback for those with very sensitive skin), reviewers note that the light, fresh scent is pleasant and not overwhelming.

Best Moisturizing

Osea Anti-Aging Body Balm Firming Moisturizer

$54 at Amazon$84 at Ulta$54 at Target

Ingredients: Alaria seaweed, safflower seed oil, coconut oil, passion fruit seed oil| Size: 5 oz; 9.2 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

As the name suggests, this definitely skews thicker and richer, a major win for anyone dealing with serious dryness. (But it still comes in a pump-top bottle, no need to scoop from a messy jar.) Credit a combo of natural oils—including coconut, safflower seed, and passion fruit—all of which leave your skin feeling smooth and silky, yet not in the least bit greasy. There’s also a special kind of seaweed in the mix, known for increasing firmness and elasticity.  So much so that in clinical trials, 84% of participants agreed that their skin felt firmer after just two weeks of use. Color us impressed.

Best for Improved Texture

NIVEA Skin Firming Melanin Beauty & Hydration Body Lotion

$11

$10 at Amazon$11 at Target$14 at Walgreens

Ingredients: CoQ10, argan oil| Size: 16.9 oz | Fragrance-Free: No | Cruelty-Free: No

Packed with argan oil, this moisturizer knocks out any trace of dryness or ashiness, leaving behind a beautiful radiance and glow. At the same time, coQ10, a powerful antioxidant, helps to firm and improve skin elasticity. Happy reviewers rave about improvements in tone and texture, and about how super hydrating it is, too.

Best With Retinol

Naturium Skin-Renewing Retinol Body Lotion

$28

$25 at Amazon$26 at Ulta$26 at Target

Ingredients: Retinol, allantoin, shea butter| Size: 8 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Dara Spearman, M.D., a board-certified dermatologist in Fort Wayne, Indiana, says retinol is one of the best ingredients for mature skin—and that holds true for products meant for both the face and body. The only issue? Retinol is notoriously irritating, with a high likelihood of irksome side effects like redness and flaking. Not with this formula, though. It relies on a unique form of encapsulated retinol that’s delivered slowly, improving tone, texture, and firmness without any unwanted issues. There’s allantoin in the mix, a great skin-soother that further helps to combat redness. FYI, since retinol is the star of the show here, it’s best to save this for nighttime use, and/or to make sure to use SPF after if you’re using it in the morning. (Retinol increases your skin’s sensitivity to the sun.)

Best Firming

Dr. Barbara Sturm Anti-Aging Body Cream

$130 at Amazon$130 at Sephora$260 at Nordstrom

Ingredients: Grape seed oil, shea butter, Indian almond, lactic acid| Size: 7 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

There’s no shortage of natural oils and plant-based extracts in this formula, all of which work synergistically to boost firmness, offer tons of antioxidant protection, and seriously moisturize, of course. Also noteworthy: the formula’s mineral-rich glacier water can help combat irritation. Bonus points for the silky, velvety texture that absorbs lightning fast and leaves your skin feeling equally luxurious.

Best Unscented

Necessaire Body Lotion

$52

$47 at Amazon$52 at Sephora$52 at Nordstrom

Ingredients: Niacinamide, peptides, vitamin C, vitamin E| Size: 15.2 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

While many people can tolerate lightly scented products, Dr. Spearman says anyone with sensitive skin or prone to irritation should always opt for fragrance-free products. This is one of our favorites, a mega-mild pick that’s so gentle that it even boasts the National Eczema Association’s Seal of Approval. Niacinamide is one of the main ingredients, a multitasker that hydrates and has antioxidant benefits, as well as five different peptides that help with firmness. It soaks into the skin beautifully, and we also love the jumbo-size bottle.

Best for Crepey Skin

Gold Bond Age Renew Crepe Corrector Body Lotion

$12

$12 at Amazon$12 at Target$19 at Walgreens

Ingredients: Omega fatty acids, glycerin, jojoba esters | Size: 8 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

This aptly-named pick takes the cake when it comes to leaving crepey skin (you know, the kind that’s thin, with super fine wrinkles) smoother and more supple. Users saw an improvement (on the backs of their arms) after just two days of use, an impressive feat for any body lotion. And we’d be remiss not to mention the wallet-friendly price tag and the fact that it hydrates for up to 24 hours.

Best Dermatologist-Recommended

Image Skincare Body Spa Body Lotion

$37

$34 at Amazon$37 at Target$37 at Skincareessentials.com

Ingredients: Glycolic acid, shea butter, peptides, macadamia seed oil| Size: 6 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes

Dr. Spearman says this is one of her personal favorites. “As we age, our skin gets drier and rougher. This lotion is formulated with glycolic acid, peptides, and shea butter to remove dead skin, moisturize, and rejuvenate,” she says. Devoted fans love the satin-y feel and the fact that it delivers long-lasting hydration, too.