A smoky eye is the equivalent of red lipstick for your peepers—it’s classic, chic, and a little bit (or sometimes very) sexy. That’s why it’s a constant go-to for celebrities, who have provided plenty of inspo for smoky eye makeup over the years.

Of course, deeper shades are a perennial favorite, but you can create a smoky eye look in practically every color, from pretty pastels to jewel tones. To prove it, we’ve rounded up 17 of our favorite examples of smoky eye makeup, as seen on some of our favorite stars. Scroll on to see them.