Best Overall

Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Cream

$28

$19 at Amazon$37 at Ulta

$42

$25 at Walgreens

Key Ingredients: Niacinamide, peptides, hyaluronic acid, triglycerides | Skin Type: All | Size: 1.7 oz

Affectionately referred to as the “little red jar,” this iconic moisturizer has sold over 50 million units since it launched. Dr. King is a fan, noting that it “provides the ideal combination of humectants like hyaluronic acid, emollients like triglycerides, and occlusives to hydrate, support the skin barrier, and lock in moisture.”

This face cream also contains skin-smoothing peptides and niacinamide—the gold-standard ingredient Olay prides itself on—which Dr. King says boosts tone and texture. The medium-weight formula provides a plumping effect and deeply moisturizes without leaving a greasy residue behind. Some people might find the almond scent too strong, so if you’re scent-sensitive, we’d suggest checking out the fragrance-free version.

Marissa, tester with combination skin: “The cream was the perfect consistency: creamy and light. It applied very easily and absorbed nicely. My skin feels soft but firm, and my neck wrinkles look improved.”

Best Day Serum

Olay Super Serum

$35

$29 at Amazon$44 at Ulta$35 at Target

Key Ingredients: Lactic acid,niacinamide, hyaluronic acid, glycerin, vitamin C | Skin Type: All| Size: 1 oz

Dr. King stands behind Olay Super Serum, calling it “a great formulation full of helpful ingredients.” Beyond the usual suspects (niacinamide, hyaluronic acid, glycerin, and vitamin C), it contains alpha-hydroxy acid (AHA) and lactic acid. “AHAs dissolve the bonds that hold dull, dead skin cells on the skin’s surface, so the skin will gently shed, revealing smoother, brighter skin underneath,” she explains. Any skin type can benefit from this multitasking serum, but if you’re new to AHAs or have very sensitive skin, consider starting slow and working your way up to daily use.

Ali Webb, associate style editor with combination skin: “If you’re looking to explore the benefits of serums or curate a minimalist routine, Olay’s Super Serum is a great place to start. It’s easy to use and balances multiple benefits without overwhelming the skin, so you can get a hydration boost and improved tone and texture all in one product.”

Best Night Serum

Olay Face Serum

$24 at Amazon$44 at Ulta

$35

$30 at Walmart

Key Ingredients: Salicylic acid, niacinamide, lactic acid, glycerin, and peptides | Skin Type: All | Size: 1 oz

In addition to Super Serum, Olay created a version specifically for your evening wind-down routine. This 5-in-1 face serum features, you guessed it, five key ingredients to work overnight while you’re getting your beauty sleep: salicylic acid, niacinamide, lactic acid, glycerin, and peptides.

To use, cleanse your skin in the evening as you normally would to remove dirt, oil, and makeup. Apply the serum evenly all over your face and neck. Keep in mind that the AHAs in this product may make your skin more sensitive to the sun, so make sure you don’t skip SPF in the morning.

Eden Stuart, editor with combination/oily skin: “Olay’s Super Serum Night Repair delivers a noticeable difference in hydration and radiance overnight—literally—while working in the long term to help cultivate a more even skin tone. And it does all that at under $50—a total steal, in my opinion.”

Best for Body

Olay Body Lotion

$11

$11 at Amazon

$23

$11 at WalmartView on CVS

Key Ingredients: Niacinamide, vitamin B3 | Skin Type: All | Size: 17 oz

If you’re an avid lotion applier, may we introduce you to the Olay Niacinamide Age-Defying Body Lotion? The niacinamide and vitamin B3 complex in this lotion are key ingredients that improve skin tone and texture, leaving you with smoother, more hydrated skin each day. The formula is nongreasy and fast-absorbing, so you can apply it and go about your day without feeling sticky. Apply daily and fall in love with the results—bonus points if you apply right after showering for super soft skin and the ultimate self-care moment.

Cher Checchio, copy editor with dry/sensitive skin: “Looking for a lotion that isn’t greasy and does more than simply soften skin? This Olay lotion will check a variety of boxes. It does everything from hydrating and retaining moisture to improving skin tone and texture. It’s a great addition to a mature skincare routine.”

Best Cleanser

Olay Cleansing Melts + Retinol

$7

$6 at Amazon$10 at Target

$25

$10 at Walmart

Key Ingredients: Vitamin C, hyaluronic acid, or retinol | Skin Type: Normal, oily, dry combination | Size: 12 dissolving pads per pack

Never be thwarted by TSA guidelines at security again with this clever take on facial cleanser. The Olay Cleansing Melts are water-activated pads that transform into a rejuvenating micro-bubble lather. This cleanser cleans, tones (with the use of retinol), and refreshes skin after each use. To use, simply soak the product in your hand and rub your hands together to activate it before washing your face as normal. This product is available in three different versions—vitamin C, hyaluronic acid, and retinol—so you can choose the best fit for your skin. Did we mention it’s fragrance-free? (This makes it ideal for those with sensitive skin.)

Olivia Hancock, senior beauty editor with dry skin: “Whether you’re wearing makeup or your skin feels oily after a long day, these cleansers are great at getting rid of everything without drying out your skin. Because the squares are so compact and mess-free, this has become the cleanser I always travel with.”

Best With Vitamin C

Olay Vitamin C Lightweight Face Moisturizer

$30

$29 at Amazon$30 at Target

$12

$12 at Walmart

Key Ingredients: Vitamin C, niacinamide, lactic acid | Skin Type: Normal, oily, dry combination | Size: 1.7 oz

Wish you could start every morning with a glass of freshly squeezed orange juice? Well, here’s a skincare substitute: the Olay Vitamin C Moisturizer contains a fresh citrus scent to help you put your best face forward. This lightweight face cream helps even skin tone and reduce dark spots, thanks to its star ingredient, vitamin C. It also contains niacinamide to help hydrate and lactic acid to gently exfoliate. Our tester, Katie, noted that it even looks great layered underneath makeup since it absorbs quickly and creates a smooth base.

Katie, tester with combination skin: “This moisturizer left a glow on my face after using it. I felt like my skin looked so much brighter and clearer immediately. I noticed my makeup applied better and smoother over it, without any residue or shine, even throughout the day.”